The Equal Pay Goal: Lessons from Women’s Soccer Battles

by Jon Scaccia December 9, 2024

For decades, women’s soccer has inspired fans with electrifying matches and fearless athletes. Yet behind the scenes, many players have fought a different kind of battle—one for fair pay. In this fight for equality, the United States Women’s National Team (USWNT) and Australia’s Matildas have stood as symbols of resilience. Each team used its unique approach to address wage disparities, teaching us lessons that extend far beyond the soccer field.

The History Behind the Game

Women’s soccer didn’t always have the spotlight. The sport struggled against societal norms, with players often sidelined by discrimination. In the U.S., Title IX spurred a surge in women’s participation in sports, laying the groundwork for the USWNT’s rise. Meanwhile, Australia’s Matildas began gaining traction in the late 20th century, facing similar hurdles.

By the 1990s, both teams had shown their potential to capture global attention. Yet their successes on the pitch were overshadowed by glaring inequalities off it. The USWNT and Matildas brought in record crowds and revenue yet were compensated far less than their male counterparts.

Two Teams, Two Strategies

USWNT: A Fight in the Courts

In 2016, five USWNT players filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), alleging wage discrimination by U.S. Soccer. Armed with data showing they earned significantly less than the men’s team despite greater success, the players demanded change. Their fight culminated in a $24 million settlement in 2022, including a landmark agreement to equalize prize money and other benefits.

Matildas: Power in Numbers

In 2015, the Matildas went on strike, canceling a sold-out U.S. tour to protest unfair pay. Their bold move, supported by the Professional Footballers Australia union, led to a historic 2019 agreement. Under the new deal, Australia’s male and female players now share revenue equally, with improved travel conditions and maternity leave policies.

Real-World Implications

The journeys of these two teams underscore the importance of strategy in achieving change. The USWNT leveraged legal frameworks, while the Matildas used collective action. Both approaches highlight the power of teamwork, persistence, and public support in driving systemic change.

For soccer coaches, club managers, and players, these stories offer actionable lessons. Equal pay isn’t just a legal or ethical issue—it’s a signal of an organization’s commitment to fairness and inclusivity.

1. Coaching:

• Promote a culture of equality by ensuring all players receive equal opportunities, training resources, and recognition.
• Teach players the value of teamwork and advocacy, both on and off the field.

2. Player Development:

• Encourage young players to stand up for their rights and value their contributions.
• Highlight role models like the USWNT and Matildas to inspire confidence and resilience.

3. Club Management:

• Invest in equal pay policies and transparent compensation structures.
• Use revenue-sharing models that reflect players’ contributions to the sport’s growth.

The Final Whistle

The fight for equal pay in women’s soccer isn’t over, but the USWNT and Matildas have proven that progress is possible. By taking bold steps, they’ve paved the way for a future where talent—not gender—determines value. Coaches, players, and clubs everywhere should take note: the pursuit of equality isn’t just good ethics; it’s good for the game.

Are you ready to delve deeper into the science and strategy of soccer? 

This Week in Soccer offers you a unique blend of expert analysis, engaging infographics, and practical insights. Subscribe to our newsletter and stay ahead of the game with the latest in soccer analytics and coaching strategies. Make the move from spectator to strategist. Subscribe now!