Soccer Heading and Player Safety

by Jon Scaccia November 18, 2024

How many headers did you see last weekend? That iconic move—players leaping to meet a flying soccer ball with their heads—has shaped the game for generations. But behind the drama lies a growing concern: what is the true cost of heading? Recent research shines a light on how we understand this fundamental skill and its impact on player safety. Spoiler alert: the answers aren’t as clear-cut as you might think.

Heading into the Data

Heading is not just any soccer move; it’s a defining skill. Whether it’s scoring goals or blocking shots, headers have high stakes. But this systematic review uncovered a troubling reality: studies on heading are inconsistent and incomplete. Out of 71 studies reviewed, only 61% even defined what a header is, and fewer than one-quarter gave operational definitions. This is like trying to measure success in a game without defining the rules.

This lack of clarity isn’t just academic. It makes comparing studies and drawing conclusions about safety almost impossible. For coaches and players, this inconsistency means guidelines on when, where, and how to head the ball safely are more guesswork than science.

A Global Concern with Gaps

One major motivator for studying soccer heading is its potential link to long-term brain health. Neurodegenerative diseases, such as chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), have been associated with repeated head impacts. Soccer, uniquely among sports, encourages intentional head-to-ball contact. While some associations are reported, the lack of consistent data on heading limits our understanding of its true risks.

Imagine trying to figure out why a player keeps getting injured but only having part of the picture. That’s what scientists are dealing with. Some studies use subjective player recall years after they’ve retired. Others rely on high-tech gadgets like inertial measurement units (IMUs) to track impacts in real-time. But even with technology, there’s no standard for what counts as a header or how to measure its intensity.

Why Standardization Matters

What’s the big deal about defining a header? Consider this: a defensive header to clear the ball from the penalty box is vastly different from a high-speed goal attempt. Yet, studies lump these actions together without distinguishing between intentional and unintentional impacts, like accidental head-to-ball contact.

To put it in perspective, it’s like measuring the danger of driving without distinguishing between city traffic and highway speeds. The risks—and the solutions—are completely different.

What We Can Learn from the Data

Despite the chaos in how data is collected, some trends are emerging. Here’s what we know:

• Age and Experience Matter: Younger players and those new to the game may be at greater risk due to developing skills and physical vulnerabilities.
• Gender Disparities: Female players often face different injury mechanisms, like ball-to-head contact, compared to males.
• Match vs. Practice: Match play typically involves more intense and frequent heading than practice sessions, suggesting game-day protocols might need stricter oversight.

These findings hint at where coaches and leagues can step in. But without standardized metrics, making evidence-based decisions remains a challenge.

Applications

So, what can we do with this information? Here’s how the findings apply to soccer coaching, player development, and club management:

Coaching:

• Rethink Practice Drills: Focus on controlled heading exercises that teach proper technique while limiting repetitive impacts.
• Use Technology Wisely: Incorporate video reviews or wearable tech to monitor heading frequency and intensity.

Player Development:

• Start Young, Teach Right: Prioritize foundational skills to ensure players understand safe and effective heading techniques from the start.
• Balance Risks and Rewards: Adjust training loads to minimize unnecessary exposure for youth players.

Club Management:

• Advocate for Guidelines: Push for clear, standardized heading definitions and data collection methods at all levels of play.
• Promote Player Safety: Invest in programs that educate players and staff about the potential risks of heading.

Closing Thoughts

Soccer is a game of precision, passion, and strategy, and heading is a vital part of it. But as this research highlights, the lack of clear, standardized data on heading creates risks we can’t ignore. For coaches, players, and managers alike, the path forward involves embracing science to protect the beautiful game—and everyone who plays it.

Are you ready to rethink heading in soccer? Share your thoughts below or sign up for our newsletter to stay informed about player safety and coaching innovation.

Elevate your understanding of the beautiful game with ‘This Week in Soccer’.

Subscribe now to our newsletter and be part of a community that transforms theoretical knowledge into practical mastery. Don’t miss out on the chance to access groundbreaking insights and redefine your approach to soccer. Subscribe today!