Does a Long-Term Contract Really Improve Soccer Performance?

by Jon Scaccia November 13, 2024

When a talented soccer player signs a long-term contract, fans and coaches alike may assume that they’ll see a stellar performance. After all, security in a player’s position should free them to focus on the game, right? However, new research challenges this assumption, revealing that contract length may not actually drive increased effort or improve performance for every player. So, what does this mean for coaching and player development?

This blog post delves into the findings from an 18-season study of Italian Serie A players (link will download a .pdf), in which researchers examined how contract length impacts player performance. By exploring this study, we’ll uncover why longer contracts may not always yield the expected results and discuss what this means for coaching strategies and player development.

What the Research Says: Long-Term Contracts and Performance

The study analyzed data from thousands of Serie A players across multiple seasons to see if those with longer contracts consistently performed better than those with shorter contracts. While it’s common to think that a stable contract would motivate players, the results were surprising. For the average player, a long-term contract did not significantly change their performance.

In fact, players with shorter contracts often displayed similar levels of effort and effectiveness. Interestingly, players who did benefit from long contracts tended to be younger, non-Italian players, or those on loan. This finding suggests that certain groups might respond to contract security differently based on their age, nationality, or career circumstances.

Why Contract Length Might Not Motivate Every Player

One of the biggest takeaways from this study is that soccer players, much like workers in other high-skilled fields, don’t necessarily perform better when they know they have job security. The reason? Performance in soccer often depends on factors beyond just motivation; team dynamics, coaching style, and personal skill all play significant roles.

Moreover, in a competitive field like professional soccer, players are constantly evaluated, and many have the chance to sign new contracts at the end of each season. This flexibility creates a continuous incentive to perform well, as future contracts depend on cumulative performance over time, not just on the current contract’s length.

Key Findings in Player Motivation and Contract Length

1. Younger Players May Benefit More: A long-term contract could provide a crucial confidence boost for younger players. Securing a multi-year deal early in their career may help them focus on improving their skills, leading to better overall performance.
2. Foreign Players Respond to Stability: Non-Italian players, who may face challenges adjusting to a new country or team culture, seem to benefit from the stability that long-term contracts provide. Knowing they’ll be around for several seasons could help them integrate better with their team, enhancing their performance.
3. Loan Players Show Higher Motivation: Loan players who receive long contracts may be more motivated to prove their worth. They often have to compete for a spot, and a long contract with a new team might push them to show that they are valuable assets.

These findings challenge the notion that long-term contracts alone can motivate top performance. Instead, they suggest that coaches and team managers should consider each player’s unique needs when designing contracts.

Implications for Soccer Coaching and Player Development

The takeaway from this study isn’t that long-term contracts are ineffective—it’s that they may be most useful when tailored to specific types of players. Coaches and managers can use these findings to structure contracts in ways that encourage performance based on a player’s career stage and background.

Applications

• For Coaches: Understanding that younger players and foreign players might respond positively to contract stability, coaches can work to reinforce the confidence boost these players feel when signing a long-term contract. Building a training and mentoring environment that matches this stability may further enhance performance.
• For Player Development: Coaches and development teams can focus on creating stability for younger players, especially during their early career years. Offering structured pathways for these players, such as contract extensions tied to performance milestones, can help maintain high effort levels throughout their contracts.
• For Club Management: Instead of applying a one-size-fits-all approach, clubs might consider selectively offering long-term contracts to young players and those adjusting to a new country or team culture. This approach allows management to maximize the potential of each player while remaining flexible with the rest of the roster.

In soccer and beyond, motivation is complex, and simply extending a contract may not be enough to guarantee improved performance. By understanding the unique factors that influence different players, coaches and managers can make smarter, data-driven decisions that contribute to overall team success.

Are you ready to delve deeper into the science and strategy of soccer? 

This Week in Soccer offers you a unique blend of expert analysis, engaging infographics, and practical insights. Subscribe to our newsletter and stay ahead of the game with the latest in soccer analytics and coaching strategies. Make the move from spectator to strategist. Subscribe now!